Skip to main content

3 True Crime Books About Unsolved Cold Cases You'll Never Forget

I'm a Tennessee-based freelance writer with a passion for true crime, a thirst for knowledge, and an obsession with lists.

Thanks to science, cold case squads around the world are experiencing greater success in solving cases once believed to be unsolvable.

The following three books focus on cases many fear will remain unsolvable, despite many advances in science, because of time passed and lack of evidence. These cases involve children and adults whose stories you will never forget.

Maybe someday, someone will solve these mysteries and bring closure to the families in desperate need of answers.

1. The Boy in the Box: The Unsolved Case of America’s Unknown Child by David Stout

He was found in a cardboard box on the side of the road in the Fox Chase section of Philadelphia. He would become known as "The Boy in the Box."

"The Boy in the Box" by David Stout

"The Boy in the Box" by David Stout

No one came forward to claim the little boy, who was estimated to be between the ages of four and six. He was obviously malnourished, weighing no more than an average two-year-old.

And he’d been beaten to death.

Who in the world could be responsible for such a vicious act against a precious child?

Some investigators were so distraught they would literally spend the rest of their lives searching for the answer to that question. At the same time, young boys who viewed the flyers around town asking for information would be so touched by the nameless child they would become police officers themselves, hoping they could one day solve the mystery surrounding his death.

In his 2008 book The Boy in the Box, author David Stout recalls the case of the little boy who would later be given the more respectful moniker of America’s Unknown Child and the long, hard search to identify him and find his killers—all to no avail.

Many of the stories I read on a daily basis touch me deeply, but none so much as this one. I cried as I read about the fatal injuries to this little boy. I cried as he lay unclaimed at the morgue. I cried as I read about the detectives who visited his grave every year on the anniversary of his discovery.

To sum it up: I cried all the way through this book.

The Boy In The Box is an excellent book, telling one of the most heartbreaking stories you will ever read. It’s a book that should have never been written but had to be. And not only do I recommend you read it, but I strongly encourage you to share the story with others.

Hopefully, one day soon, before another half-century passes, someone, somewhere, can name America’s Unknown Child.

2. Unsolved Disappearances in the Great Smoky Mountains by Juanitta Baldwin and Ester Grubb

Authors Juanitta Baldwin and Ester Grubb kick off the book with “The Big Three”: Dennis Lloyd Martin, Thelma Pauline Melton, and Trenny Lynn Gibson. Although I believed I had learned all there was to know about this trio of unsolved disappearances, I was surprised to find I had not.

While not anything that changes my own personal theories, it was facts that made the people more personal—something difficult to obtain from archived newspaper articles and television footage, with information related directly from the families by weaving in local rumors of related interest.

"Unsolved Disappearances in the Great Smoky Mountains" by Juanitta Baldwin and Ester Grubb

"Unsolved Disappearances in the Great Smoky Mountains" by Juanitta Baldwin and Ester Grubb

Next, readers are introduced to the “red-haired boy” who was found frozen in the snow in the Sugarlands community in 1915. He would remain in an unmarked grave for more than six decades until finally, a family member stepped forward to claim him.

Then it’s on to the story of Abe Carroll Ramsey, the three-year-old son of a moonshiner. When the little boy disappeared from his own yard in March 1919, local townsfolk searched frantically for the lad, to no avail. Three stories have been told about this disappearance. The truth is in there somewhere, and it is shocking and heartbreaking.

Just as readers recover from the gut-wrenching of little Abe’s likely demise, they are introduced to William Bradford Bishop, Jr., a U.S. Foreign Services officer whose station wagon was found abandoned in the park in March 1976. Much to the surprise of park rangers, Bishop was wanted for questioning in the deaths of five family members.

Scroll to Continue

Read More From CrimeWire

And last but certainly not least, Robert Eric Rudolph—today better known as the Olympic Park Bomber and a native of Andrews, North Carolina—is featured when it’s believed he has returned to his mountain roots to avoid arrest for bombing the New Woman All Women abortion clinic in Birmingham, Alabama on January 29, 1998. Little did authorities know the true extent of his crimes.

Unsolved Disappearances in the Great Smoky Mountains is a thoroughly interesting read about crimes from one of the nation’s most popular parks.

3. Ted and Ann: The Mystery of a Missing Child and Her Neighbor Ted Bundy by Rebecca Morris

In 1961, eight-year-old Ann Marie Burr disappeared in the middle of the night from her Tacoma, Washington, home. The only clue in her disappearance was a slightly more opened living room window than had been before the family returned to bed. The family dog had been stirred in the night, but Don and Beverly Burr didn’t take it to be an alarm-raising bark.

"Ted and Ann: The Mystery of a Missing Child and Her Neighbor Ted Bundy" by Rebecca Morris

"Ted and Ann: The Mystery of a Missing Child and Her Neighbor Ted Bundy" by Rebecca Morris

Despite strong efforts of police and community, little Ann Marie would never be found—her fate only to be assumed but never confirmed.

What no one could know is, only a couple of blocks away, there lived a serial killer in the making. Theodore “Ted” Robert Bundy was working as a newspaper delivery boy and enjoying nocturnal activities such as window peeping and burglary.

When Ted was captured for the last time in Florida, investigators from all over traveled to the Sunshine State asking about their unsolved cases, and Tacoma police were no different. One of their foremost questions was about Ann Marie.

Ted denied his involvement, with the exception of one single nod of the head in affirmation to a lone individual in the days before his execution. But Ted did a hypothetical scenario of the abduction that many believe was too precise to be false.

For several years now, author Rebecca Morris has studied this cold case and followed the movements of Ted Bundy just before Ann’s disappearance and his criminal modus operandi, comparing them and now putting them into a well-organized, clear timeline in her new book Ted and Ann: The Mystery of a Missing Child and Her Neighbor Ted Bundy.

I absolutely love a book that gives me all the facts and allows me to make my own decision before the author plainly states his or hers. And that’s exactly what Morris did. Her opinion only comes into play in the last two paragraphs of the book, giving me plenty of time to form my own theories—in this case, she and I agreed.

You may think you’ve read all there is to know about America’s most famous serial killer, but you haven’t. In all the books I’ve read about Bundy, Ann Burr has never been mentioned, that I can recall. And since his other crimes were only mentioned as necessary, this was fresh material. We all know fresh material as relates to Ted Bundy is a bit hard to come by these days, right?

You definitely want to put Ted and Ann on your reading list. It’s a new spin on an old story—in more ways than one.

Questions & Answers

Question: What is your theory about what happened to Trenny Lynn Gibson?

Answer: I believe Trenny likely fell into a ravine or old mine shaft. I know they searched quite hard for her but there's just too many nooks and crannies in the area where a body could be easily hidden (either by accident or on purpose) and never found.

© 2017 Kim Bryan


Kim Bryan (author) on January 05, 2017:

Oh boy, do I have an opinion on Darlie Routier! lol Actually working on an article on her so stay tuned. And thanks so much for reading!

Suzie from Carson City on January 05, 2017:

Well Kim, as usual I'm quick to jump on your new hubs. This one is very interesting. Unfortunately, I have a stack of books so high and an additional special "list" that is so long, I doubt I can live long enough to read them all......damn it! If we didn't have to eat, sleep and occasionally put one foot in front of the other, I could literally read 24/7....or at least when I'm not on HP.

Cold cases drive me nuts. LOL. I can somewhat understand some of the much older ones having gone cold but not more recent ones when technology & testing is so sensitive and accurate.

You and I definitely have that "real life crime bug." my interest and fascination for it goes way back...BTW, been meaning to ask you if you have an opinion on the Darlie Routier case.....Texas mother of 3 boys, in prison on death row for the slaughter of her 2 older sons.....etc. I would be shocked if you aren't familiar with this case....very high profile at the time. I can't get that one out of a stubborn corner in my mind... Paula

Related Articles